Logo
text us
Logo

Choosing the Right Adoption Agency for Birth Parents

a woman talking with a girl

A Comprehensive Guide to Choosing the Right Adoption Agency for Birth Parents

Adoption is a life-changing decision, and for birth parents, working with the right adoption agency is vital in ensuring a smooth and positive experience. With numerous agencies available, it can be overwhelming to determine where to start.

By doing research, seeking recommendations, and considering agency culture, you can narrow down your options and ensure you are working with an agency that wants to meet and exceed your expectations.

Know Your Adoption Goals and Preferences

Because adoption is a significant decision, you must review and consider all of your options. You must work with an adoption agency that understands your needs and supports your goals.

Knowing your adoption preferences and goals can help you choose the most suitable adoption agency that will support you throughout the process and ensure that your child is placed with a loving and supportive family. You deserve to work with an adoption agency that aligns with and respects your beliefs and values.

Considering Adoption Agencies

Hands forming a house with building blocks

Birth parents must ensure that an adoption agency has a good reputation and is appropriately licensed. Licensing assesses and certifies an agency’s capabilities, ensuring it adheres to best practices and follows all necessary regulations.
You can verify the agency’s license through reputable organizations, such as the attorney general’s office in the state where the agency is located. This allows you to confirm that the agency’s license is current and in compliance with laws and regulations and check if any complaints or lawsuits have been filed against it.


A trustworthy agency should be transparent and willing to share its license with you. They should also provide external resources that you can investigate on your own. When birth parents know that an agency meets all state requirements, they can feel more confident in the agency’s ability to handle their case professionally and ethically. This assurance helps you proceed with confidence, knowing that if you decide giving a child up for adoption, they will be placed in a loving, safe family.

The guidance that follows will assist you in learning more about your chosen adoption agency:

  1. Online Research

The internet is a very helpful tool for finding out some basic information about adoption agencies. Look for reputable local agencies first and check out their websites to learn more about their mission, values, and what support services they offer to birth parents. 

You should expect your chosen agency to have a clear mission and values and be knowledgeable as to what resources they will provide to you during and after your pregnancy.

  1. Personal Recommendations 

Consult with family members, close friends, or acquaintances who have worked with adoption agencies. Ask them about their specific experiences, any challenges they faced, and whether they would recommend the agency they worked with.

The agency you work with should be able to provide you with stories from birth parents and adoptive families they have previously worked with. These endorsements will provide you with a first-hand account of experiences with the agency, from someone who was once in your shoes.

Working with a Supportive Agency

a couple smiling at each other

Selecting an agency can be a challenging process for birth parents, as adoption is an emotional journey. Fortunately, you can get help from a variety of qualified professionals throughout this process.

Birth parents typically have the option to find adoption agencies. Working with an agency near you offers several advantages, including first-hand knowledge of local support services, counseling, and potential adoptive families. Your agency should be willing to connect you with outside resources and qualified professionals.

You can feel confident about being supported during and after your journey when your agency is aware of the options available to you in your community. Choosing adoption agencies that offer essential support can alleviate the challenges and uncertainties you may experience as a birth parent.

Consultations with Your Agency

Consultations serve as the initial point of contact between birth parents and adoption agencies. They are an opportunity for birth parents to express their concerns, share their preferences, and understand the adoption process better.

You should consider your consultation as an opportunity to get to know the adoption agency and determine whether it is a good fit for you and your child. During this visit, be sure to ask plenty of questions. 

It may be helpful to write down questions ahead of your appointment so you don’t forget anything. Remember, no questions are too big or too small! You should expect the agency to be patient, respectful, and thorough in their answers.

Transparency and Communication

parents with their child talking with a professional

Transparency and communication are the basic building blocks of any successful adoption agency. By adopting transparent practices and promoting effective communication, your agency should establish trust, provide clarity, and empower you throughout the adoption process. 

A successful adoption journey is built on transparency. For you to make appropriate choices, you should be fully informed about each aspect of the entire process. Transparency is valued highly by Open Arms Adoptions because it fosters a trusting environment that allows birth parents to engage in an active role in the adoption planning process. They prioritize transparency and open lines of communication to ensure a positive and fulfilling experience for all parties involved.

Financial Considerations

Financial considerations are a critical aspect of the adoption process for birth parents. Your agency should clearly outline how expenses are handled, including living expenses and legal and medical costs. When agencies are forthcoming about this information, you can feel confident that you are being respected and supported in every way possible.

Legal Guidance

Seeking legal guidance while working with adoption agencies is crucial for parents considering making an adoption plan. These professionals provide the necessary legal assistance and resources to ensure birth parents navigate the adoption process with confidence and peace of mind.

Your agency should be connected with attorneys who are experienced specifically in adoption. These professionals are well-versed in protecting birth parents’ rights and can answer your questions openly and honestly.

Birth parents who adhere to the advice given by legal experts can make well-informed choices and successfully make their adoption plan.

Assessing Cultural Sensitivity

parents happily bonding with their child

Cultural sensitivity plays a crucial role in the adoption process, particularly for birth parents seeking an adoption agency that respects and values their cultural background. Understanding the importance of cultural sensitivity ensures a positive experience for all parties involved.

Cultural socialization in adoption refers to the ways adoptive parents teach their children about their birth heritage, traditions, values, and cultural history. For children, developing a strong sense of ethnic identity can contribute to their overall sense of self and well-being. Research shows that when adoptive parents honor their adopted child’s ethnic identity, there is a positive influence on the child’s mental, emotional, and social health

Adoptive parents can honor your child’s culture by celebrating cultural festivals, storytelling, and teaching them about their culture’s norms and values. If this is important to you, your agency should work to connect you with like-minded families and respect your wishes.

Trust Your Instincts

Using your natural instincts can be a powerful guide through the adoption process. It allows you to tap into your inherent knowledge and intuition, helping you make decisions that align with your deepest values and dreams for your child. 

While adoption agencies provide valuable support and resources, it is ultimately you who has the final say in choosing the adoptive family for your child. By trusting your instincts and working with an agency that meets and exceeds your expectations, you are empowered to identify the best family to raise your child, ensuring they will have a loving and stable future.

Exceptional Agencies Support Birth Parents

Making an adoption plan is a loving and selfless decision that significantly impacts birth parents’ lives. Choosing the right adoption agency to partner with makes all the difference in the success of your unique adoption process. 

Your agency should be respectful, transparent, and supportive to you both during the pregnancy and after the child is born. The tips mentioned in this article aim to help you understand what you can expect from a reputable, honorable, and exceptional adoption agency. 

During this emotional time in your life, you deserve to be treated with the utmost respect and dignity, knowing the agency you have partnered with is your biggest advocate. Working with an agency that upholds the tips mentioned in this article contributes to a positive experience for all involved in the adoption process.

Open Arms Adoptions is here to support you throughout the adoption process. If you are inspired to move forward and would like more information, call or text Open Arms Adoptions at 330-697-4751 today!

Read More Articles
Creating Forever Families
Creating Forever Families Through Adoption
Logo

Open Arms Adoptions is 501(c)3 non-profit agency licensed by the State of Ohio.

Our mission is to provide a loving, stable home to every child in need. We work tirelessly to create an environment that embraces the unique set of circumstances each of our birth parents, prospective adoptive parents and children bring to us. 
Locations
Main Office
11 River St., Ste. B
Kent, OH 44240
Central Ohio Office:*
11 N High St.
Canal Winchester, OH 43110
Delaware Office:*
18 E. William St.
Delaware, OH 43015
*by appointment only. All correspondence should be mailed to the Kent address
© 2024 Open Arms Adoptions, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy